Wednesday, 14 August 2013

SC suo moto notice against ARY for showing Ziarat Residency Attack Video



SUPREME COURT OF PAKISTAN
 
                                                                              
 
 
PRESS RELEASE
 
 
HCJP TAKES SUO MOTU NOTICE ON ARY NEWS CHANNEL PROGRAM “AB TAK” TELECAST ON 13.08.2013
 
 
 
            The Hon’ble Chief Justice of Pakistan has taken notice of the ARY News Channel program “Ab Tak” hosted by Ms Sadaf Abdul Jabbar telecast on 13.08.2013 on a note of the Registrar. In the said program video of attack on the Ziarat Residency was shown. The Hon’ble Chief Justice of Pakistan has directed for hearing of the above matter on 15.08.2013 at Branch Registry Quetta along with Constitution Petition No. 77/2010. The note of the Registrar is reproduced below:-
 
“As per HCJ direction, the Chairman, PEMRA was asked to provide us a CD/DVD, together with transcript, of the Programme/Talk Show titled ‘shown on the ARY News TV Channel on 13.8.2013. The Anchor Ms Sadaf Abdul Jabbar conducted the show with Zahid Hamid and Raza Roomi as discussants. The Programme starts with a visual disclaimer as under:
“Disclaimer
Its our responsibility not to present opinion as facts. As long as distinction between fact and opinion is clear. As part of ARY philosophy we bring diverse opinions to enrich and empower our viewers. This program may contains opinions of host and guest which do not necessarily reflect that of the organization. For more information and give feedback visit our website
 
 
The Anchor starts the Programme by saying that she is showing selected visuals of the video hosted on the Internet and that she has withheld some parts of the video, which are not fit to view by the general public. The video reveals that contrary to the claims made by the security agencies that the Ziarat Residency wherein Quaid-e-Azam spent his last days was attacked by the terrorists with rockets fired/bombs, etc, whereas an actual fact it was exploded from within as the terrorists/militants were carrying gas cylinders. She states that the militants entered the venue after killing the two guards on duty and carried out the operation. There were about 5 – 6 militants involved who were wearing masks on their faces, equipped with the latest weapons/bombs, having gas cylinders in their hands. They started breaking the frames of photographs and then collected the photographs and other articles in one place, sprayed petrol over it and put it on fire. The militants are also shown lowering the national flag and tearing the same and raising instead the flag of Balochistan Libration Army (BLA). Thereafter, a massive blast occurred and the Residency caught fire/collapsed. In the background of the video, it is shown that the same has been made by the BLA.
 
2.         After showing these visuals, she invited comments from Zahid Hamid who blames the increasing incidents of militancy/violence on the political leadership for being ineffective and the Judiciary for failing to convict the accused persons involved in heinous incidents of violence/militancy. Raza Roomi also gives his comments but these were limited to the current situation on boarder with India . He argues for handling the situation in a manner to resolve the Kashmir dispute and achieve other objectives through peaceful means.
 
3.         Obviously, as acknowledged by the Anchor, only selected parts of the video were shown giving gory details of the sacrilegious attack on the national monument known as Quaid-e-Azam Residency and the profane acts of burning the photographs/national flag etc. No doubt, for an ordinary viewer, the narrations of events/video clips are fairly disturbing. The Programme must have hurt the feelings/sentiments of the people who watched it. Showing such material seems to be infringement of the provisions of the Constitution/Law.  Article 5 of the Constitution states as under:
 
“(1)      Loyalty to the State is the basic duty of every citizen.
            (2)       Obedience to the Constitution and law is the inviolable obligation of every citizen wherever he may be and of every other person for the time being within Pakistan .”
 
 
4.         On the other hand Article 19A of the Constitution provides that:
            “Every citizen shall have the right to have access to information in all matters of public importance subject to regulation and reasonable restrictions imposed by law.“
 
 
5.         Similarly, Article 19 of the Constitution provides that:
 
 
            “Every citizen shall have the right to freedom of speech and expression, and there shall be freedom of the press, subject to any reasonable restrictions imposed by law in the interest of the glory of Islam or the integrity, security or defence of Pakistan or any part thereof, friendly relations with foreign States, public order, decency or morality, or in relation to contempt of court, commission of or incitement to an offence.”
 
6.         Undoubtedly, the right to freedom of expression and freedom of the press are qualified subject to law and other requirements. Various laws qualify the freedom of expression. However, the PEMRA Rules 2009 made under Section 39 of the PEMRA Ordinance 2002 and the Code of Conduct for Media Broadcasters or Cable TV Operators Programmes made under said rules states that no programme shall be aired which:
 
                        “1(e)    is likely to encourage and incite violence or contains anything against maintenance of law and order or which promotes anti-national or anti-state attitudes;
 
                        1(j)       brings into contempt Pakistan or its people or tends to undermine its integrity or solidarity as an independent and sovereign country;
 
1(n)     anything which tends to glorify crime or criminals;“
 
 
7.         Furthermore, Section 11-W of the Anti-Terrorism Act, 1997 also puts restrictions on dissemination of objectionable material and the same is made punishable offence.
 
 
8.         It may be noted that the Supreme Court passed an order in Constitution Petition No. 77/2010 (President Balochistan High Court Bar Association v. Federation of Pakistan and others) reported as 2012 SCMR 1958, wherein reliance is also placed on Section 11-W of the Anti-Terrorism Act, 1997 and relevant portion thereof is reproduced as under:
            “…49(12).      Mr. S.M.Zafar, learned counsel appearing for the FC had placed on record sufficient material, perusal whereof suggests that whenever there is any incident of killing innocent persons both uniformed and civilian, the newspapers come forward to issue publication regarding the responsibility be different organizations which increases a sense of insecurity among the people of Balochistan. Such publication is contrary to the provisions of section 11-W of the Anti-Terrorism Act, 1997 which reads as under:
           
            “Printing, publishing, or disseminating any material to incite hatred or giving projection to any person convicted for a terrorist act or any proscribed organization or an organization placed under observation or anyone concerned in terrorism.— (1) A person commits an offence if he prints, publishes or disseminates any material, whether by audio or video-cassettes or by written, photographic, electronic, digital, wall-chalking or any other method which incites religious, sectarian or ethnic hatred or gives projection to any person convicted for a terrorist act, or any person or organization concerned in terrorism or proscribed organization or an organization placed under observation:
                        Provided that a factual news report, made in good faith, shall not be construed to mean “projection” for the purposes of this section.”
 
            49(13).            We are told that in this behalf restraint order has also been passed by the High Court of Balochistan, therefore, we confirm the order which has been passed by the High Court of Balochistan that in future the above provision of law shall be followed strictly both by the electronic and print media….”
 
9.         From the above, it is obvious that the ARY News Channel has telecast a video, which gives gory details depicting acts of sacrilege /profanity and unnecessary attempting to sensationalize the incident taken place two months before. The HCJ may therefore consider taking up this issue on 15.08.2013 in the Constitution Petition No.77/2010.” 
 
On perusal of the above note of the Registrar the Hon’ble Chief Justice has passed the following order:-
 
“Instant note may be treated as CMA. Notice to Attorney General and Advocate General Balochistan be issued. Similarly, notice be issued to C.E.O of ARY through expeditious mode of service for 15.08.2013 to appear and explain as to why proceedings in accordance with the Constitution and law may not be ordered against ARY in the national and public interest.
  
Notice be also issued to Chairman PEMRA to appear in person and explain as to what action is called for in view of the above facts and circumstances, under the law.”
  
     Zubair Sabir
Deputy Registrar / PRO

Friday, 2 August 2013

SC order in Imran Khan Contempt Case



IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PAKISTAN
(Original Jurisdiction)

PRESENT:
Mr. Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, HCJ.
Mr. Justice Jawwad S. Khawaja
Mr. Justice Sh. Azmat Saeed


Criminal Original Petition No.92 of 2013
(Contempt proceeding against Imran Khan, Chairman PTI)


On Court’s Notice:               Mr. Muneer A. Malik,
                                        Attorney General for Pakistan

For alleged contemnor:                Mr. Hamid Khan, Sr. ASC
                                        Mr. M.S. Khattak, AOR with
                                        Imran Khan
                                       
Date of hearing:                 02.08.2013

O R D E R

          Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, CJ.— Mr. Hamid Khan, Sr. ASC has placed on record two documents in the form of explanations, and he reserved his right to file detailed reply of the notice if need be. Contents of the said explanations are reproduced hereinbelow for reference:-
“EXPLANATION No. 1:              
1.     THAT Imran Khan has neither committed contempt of court under the law or the Constitution nor would even think of doing so.
2.     That Imran Khan has not started any campaign either to scandalize the Court or to bring judges into hatred, ridicule or contempt. On the contrary, he has always struggled to uphold dignity and independence of the Supreme Court and the judiciary in general.
3.     That Imran Khan believes in the rule of law, supremacy of the Constitution and independence of judiciary and, for this reason, he and his party was in the forefront of the movement for rule of law and restoration of judiciary.
4.     That, after the general elections, Imran Khan has repeatedly requested and appealed to the Supreme Court to redress the grievance of his party which has suffered massive electoral rigging at the hands of ECP and its officials. This clearly establishes that Imran Khan and his party have high expectations from the Supreme Court that justice would be done to them and that their grievance would be redressed.
5.     It is respectfully submitted that the notice may kindly be recalled.”


“EXPLANATION No. 2:
Respectfully Submitted
1.           That the press statement was made in good faith on 26th July, 2013 where in reference to the ‘Judiciary’ was for the Returning Officers and/or District Returning Officers (belonging to the Subordinate Judiciary), assigned to the election process.
2.           That Mr. Imran Khan has high respect and esteem for the Supreme Court of Pakistan and has high expectations from this Honourable Court for redressal of the grievances of the PTI arising out of the general elections.”


2.            We have drawn his attention towards one of the press clippings (Press Conference of Imran Khan dated 26.07.2013) which is reproduced hereinbelow:-


3.            Selection of the words used against judiciary, Mr. Hamid Khan argued, is in a different context, for which explanation has been given and he has pointed out the same verbally. 
4.            it was pointed out to him that the Judiciary (عدلیہ ) is required to be respected and if there is any grievance, the remedy is available under the law, but using the words “شرمناک “, prima facie, tantamounts to abusing the Judiciary. The Courts try their best to avoid asserting itself in such like situation but are compelled to look into a matter where not only the dignity or respect of a Judge but of the entire Institution is involved, and the Courts are constrained to call for an explanation. The explanations noted above have been examined carefully and are hereby rejected not being satisfactory.
5.             Learned counsel has pointed out his grievance in respect of an application which was filed in C.R.P. No.191/2012 in Constitution Petition No.87/2011 (Workers Party Pakistan v. Federation of Pakistan etc.) as far back as 08.06.2013. He further stated that the grievance of the Chairman PTI was that his application is not being disposed of. We have pointed out to him that perhaps the correct facts have not been brought into his notice as this application was returned by the office on the same day by passing the following order:-

“That the above titled C.M.A. filed by you is not entertainable on the ground that instead of making this application in a pending Review Petition the applicant should approach the appropriate forum and avail the proper remedy available under the law, if so advised.
Hence this C.M.A. in C.R.P. 191/2012 in Constitution Petition No.87/2011 is returned herewith in original being not entertainable along with its paper books.”

6.             Against the order of the Institution Officer who exercises delegated powers of the Registrar of this Court, a Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No.82/2013 was filed under Order V rule 3 of the Supreme Court Rules, 1980 and thereafter no request has been made for fixation of the case either by the Senior ASC or his AOR. The cases are fixed in the Supreme Court under policy guidelines and wherever there is any sort of urgency, a request is to be made for out of turn fixation of the case, otherwise out of total pendency, which is about 19,000 cases; it is not possible to fix all the cases and dispose them of on the same day. However, by following procedure under Supreme Court Rules, 1980 on an urgent application such appeals could possibly be heard.
7.             In addition to the above, learned counsel has been appraised about 31 Election Petitions under section 52 of the Representation of People Act, 1976 filed by the candidates of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) before Election Tribunals requesting for, inter alia, examining the thumb impressions of the voters through the process of biometric system, particularly, in respect of the following four constituencies:-


S#
Constituency No.
Election Petition No.
Title of the case
1.
NA 122 Lahore-V
No.11(315)/2013
(Imran Khan Niazi vs. Sardar Ayaz Sadiq and others)
2
NA-125 Lahore VIII
No.11(194)/2013
(Hamid Khan vs. Khawaja Saad Rafiqu and others)
3.
NA-110 Sialkot-I
No.11(344)/2013
(Usman Dar vs. Khawaja Muhammad Asif and others)
4.
NA 154 Lodhran-I
No.11(355)/2013
(Jehangir Khan Tareen vs. Muhammad Siddique Khan Baloch and others)

7.             Learned counsel requests for time to file reply of notice. Adjourned to 28.08.2013.

Chief Justice


Judge


Judge

Islamabad, the
2nd August, 2013
Nisar/*

Monday, 5 November 2012

Address of Chief Justice to Civil Officers





ADDRESS OF


THE HON’BLE CHIEF JUSTICE OF PAKISTAN

MR. JUSTICE IFTIKHAR MUHAMMAD CHAUDHRY





TO THE OFFICERS OF THE 97TH NATIONAL MANAGEMENT COURSE,                             NATIONAL SCHOOL OF PUBLIC POLICY,                                         NATIONAL MANAGEMENT COLLEGE, LAHORE ON 5.11.2012 AT ISLAMABAD


Dean, National Management College
Faculty Members
Participants of the 97th National Management Course

Ladies & Gentlemen!

I take this opportunity to welcome you all in the Supreme Court of Pakistan. The Supreme Court is the court of ultimate jurisdiction in this country. As a guardian and protector of the Constitution of Pakistan, a heavy responsibility lies upon the judges of the Supreme Court to uphold the canons of constitutional predominance and its supremacy over all other institutions and authorities. The composition, powers and jurisdiction of the Supreme Court are set out by the Constitution itself. The Court exercises original, appellate, review and advisory jurisdictions and its decisions are binding on all other courts of Pakistan.
           It gives me immense pleasure to address you, officers, who are being imparted specialized training for taking on higher responsibilities in your respective careers. It is my firm belief that strong institutions provide the bedrock for building everlasting mechanisms and sustaining socio economic, political and cultural growth and development. To establish and run these national institutions, we need a well trained and inspired bureaucracy which has the capacity and necessary means to anticipate the mounting socio economic challenges and come up with workable solutions both in the short and long run. For any developing country like Pakistan the basic requirements for enhancing national growth through competitiveness is pegged on the four pillars i.e.  (i) strengthening of institutions, (ii) Infrastructure, (iii) economic stability (iv) Health and Education. These four pillars form the foundation of achieving competitiveness for ensuring socio economic growth of our country. And these four drivers of growth can only deliver if you as civil servants put them to good use. In the last over couple of decades when I have had the good fortune of presiding as judge of the High Court and Supreme Court, I have noticed that the strength or weakness of these four drivers were directly related to the rise and fall of our national growth. 
           Institutions have assumed a significant place in the realm of socio economic growth. According to Mr. Douglas North, a Nobel Laureate in economics, institutions are simply the rules of the game in a society. The growth and development of a society mainly depends upon the rules and regulations which it adopts for itself. If the rules and regulations create a level playing field and provide equal opportunity to all under the constitution and law, then a society is bound to grow. On the other hand, if the dice is loaded against the majority, the environment will generate frustration and distortions leading to chaos and restlessness in the society.
           This proposition leads us to define what are the correct rules and regulations under the law? An appropriate answer to this proposition can only be framed if the other relevant queries are addressed:-
Do we reward merit and hard work?
Are the twin principles of rule of law and supremacy of Constitution being strictly enforced?
Do the citizens of this country trust the system and think it provides them fair opportunity to realize their dreams in a transparent manner?
Does the present system have the capacity to discourage the corrupt and rent seekers? 
Do we have a system where civil and property rights are protected and contracts are fully enforced?

If the answer to all these questions is resounding yes, then we can claim that the rules and regulations in practice here are transparent and fair. In such environment everyone will have the incentive to work hard and invest their energies and resources in their respective fields. But, if unfortunately, the answer to the above proposition is no, then I am afraid, the system is distorted and does not provide level playing field for the people to achieve in life whatever they are capable of. Unless we take a concerted effort to remove these distortions in our system it will be well nigh impossible to create favorable environment promoting competitiveness and growth.
          The Constitution of Pakistan, 1973 envisages in detail many fundamental rights to the citizen of the country. These rights, inter alia, include right of individual to be dealt with in accordance with law; security of person; safeguard as to arrest and detention; right to fair trial; inviolability of dignity of man; freedom of movement; assembly, association; trade; business or profession; speech, information; freedom to profess the religion; protection of property rights; equality of citizens; right of education; safeguard against discrimination in service and last but not the least the promotion of social and economic well being of the people.

           These fundamental rights enshrined in the Constitution have to be implemented in letter and spirit. Primarily it is the duty of the State, and to a large extent to the executive organ of the State, to ensure that these fundamental rights are not only freely available to the people but any denial of these rights is swiftly responded to and relief is provided to the citizens at a minimum cost. This is sine qua non of a truly independent and welfare State. Gone are the days when stability and security of the country was defined in terms of number of missiles and tanks as a manifestation of hard power available at the disposal of the State. Today, the concept of national security has been redefined as a polity wherein a State is bound to provide its citizens with overwhelming, social security and welfare nets and to protect their natural and civil rights at all costs. Thus, the executive branch of the country ably assisted by professionally trained civil service is bound to provide a conducive environment where the vast majority of people are able to make progress in various disciplines of their choices.

           The present day Supreme Court is alive to the fact that it has been restored to its original position by unprecedented struggle carried out by a consort of such professional classes as lawyers, students, media persons and civil society at large. Now, they expect that judicial hierarchy of the country from the court of a civil judge to that of the court of highest appeal should deliver justice to all without fear or favour in a most expeditious manner. To achieve this object, after restoration, I utilized the forum provided by the National Judicial Policy Making Committee (NJPMC) by initiating a consultation process to assess the challenges of delay and backlog of cases and how to over come it. I take much satisfaction to say that after lengthy consultation we formulated National Judicial Policy (NJP) 2009. The main crux of the Policy is to tackle conjoined menace of backlog and delay in disposal of cases. So far, the Policy has been revised a number of times and by the grace of Allah Almighty, it has delivered maximum dividends in terms of reduction of pendency and clearance of huge backlog of cases. This is not the end of the story, as the challenge is still on and I hope with cooperation of Bench and the Bar, the Policy will continue achieving its objectives. However, it is also important to point out that additional resources are required to establish new courts at district level to cater for ever increasing number of newly instituted cases in the face of ever increasing population.
           You may recall the words of Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah when he addressed Civil Servants and said that:-

“You are the servant of the state. You have nothing to do with this political party or that political party, with this government or that government. The Prime Ministers come, the Prime Ministers go, but you go on.”

           The gist of the message of our great Quaid was that the bureaucracy is one institution which is characterized by continuity. Therefore, you are doubly responsible for not only sharing your future vision and implementation plan with your political bosses but also ensuring that these plans are put into action without fear or favor. As professionals in the art of public policy and service delivery, it is your responsibility to inform the political leadership about the requirements of national competitiveness and growth.
           Now a days the Courts are seized with many issues related to enforcement of constitutional provisions. Whether it is the issue of law and order situation in Karachi or Balochistan, the footprints of weak administration and failure of implementation framework is writ large everywhere. There seems to be no cohesive efforts in terms of a national framework wherein the mega issues have been tackled in an appropriate manner. This institutional failure is directly linked to your ability to formulate national policies in the field of public policy. It also indicates the failure of implementation in cases where some forms of policy measures were recommended.
           However, all is not lost yet. We have now a very conducive environment to achieve growth and harmony. We have a vibrant media playing an effective role of whistle blower and watchdog of public interest. We have a healthy mix of political parties in the country jostling for political space with a common agenda of public welfare and last but not the least we have a truly independent judiciary which is geared to ensure the twin principles of rule of law and supremacy of constitution are enforced even if the heaven may fall. This judiciary has been trying to rewrite the constitutional and political history of this country by not only atoning sins of the past but also setting up new precedents ensuring transparency, rule of law and fundamental rights are enforced as enshrined in the Constitution. Many landmark judgments have been pronounced wherein institutions are directed to keep within their limits and let system grow. In some judgments the civil servants have been directly addressed and asked to stick to the rules and regulations come what may. In F-9 Park case reported as PLD 2010 SC 759 the Court observed that the holders of the public offices should adhere to the principle of transparency in the discharge of their duties and should refrain from implementing any order of a higher authority which is contrary to the rule and regulations. In the Karachi as well as Balochistan law and order situation cases, the Court laid stress on improved administration through induction of qualified civil servants on merit and their impartial performance of functions for good governance.  In the case of Tariq Aziz ud Din wherein the petitioner challenged the promotion or more the 50 bureaucrats to B-22, the Court struck down the notification under its power of judicial review. The Court observed that the government should frame rules and policy in order to enable the deserving civil servants to get their promotions by virtue of their qualifications, performance evaluation and experience.
           In the end I will again reiterate you to make the best of this training opportunity and gain useful knowledge and techniques to apply in your day to day job. Since most of you will be aspiring for highest positions of responsibility in your respective careers, it is incumbent upon you to broader your vision and learn from each others’ experiences and also adopt the regional and international best practices in the field of public policy and service delivery. There should be one single object in your mind and i.e. to make the service delivery to the people of Pakistan who are directly or indirectly footing the bill for your careers in public service. Regarding the institution of judiciary, as mentioned earlier, the National Judicial Policy gives us a clear direction to take on the challenge of pendency and backlog of cases in the judicial system in the country. Here, I must share with you the fact that without asking the government for a change in national laws or regulations we have initiated reform process within ourselves. We have stretched ourselves to provide expeditious justice to the people despite the absolutely low number of judicial officers vis-à-vis ever rising population. It is my firm belief that unless and until we reform ourselves individually and institutionally and until and unless we rise above our petty conflicts and unite our energies for the cause of our national growth and prosperity the dreams of our nation cannot be realized. But as I have said earlier we have necessary means both in terms of manpower and institution. We only need to be little more imaginative and dedicated and professional in our approach to provide a framework wherein all citizens of the country can plan their life in a predictable, secure and equal opportunity-based environment.  This is the recipe for our national success. And you have to play a dynamic role in achieving this success.
                     Thank you.